5DGLRRKMDWXQDWRPLNHOORQWRLPLQQRW
.HVNXV\NVLN|QNHOORRQRKMHOPRLWXV\QNURQRLWXPDDQDWRPLNHOORQUDGLRVLJQDDOLLQ
-DOXVWDMDSDULVWRMHQDVHQQXV
.HVNXV\NVLNN|RQVXXQQLWHOWXWRLPLPDDQS|\GlOOlWDLVHLQlOOl
.HVNXV\NVLN|QNHOORKDNHHUDGLRVLJQDDOLDSlLYLWWlLQ
´V\PEROLRQQLVWXQHHVWD
DWRPLNHOORQVLJQDDOLQ
OXHQQDVWD
/DLWDSDLNRLOOHHQ
$$NRNRLVHWSDULVWRWNSOQDSDLVXXVPHUNLQ³´PXNDLVHVWL
$VHQQDSDULVWRNRWHORQOXXNNXWDNDLVLQ
.XQSDULVWRWRQDVHQQHWWXNDLNNL/&'Ql\W|QVHJPHQWLWV\WW\YlWKHWNHNVLMDVLWWHQ
(WlLV\\VDWRPLNHOORVWDMDUDNHQQHWWX\PSlULVW|YRLYDWYDLNXWWDDUDGLRVLJQDDOLQ
YDVWDDQRWWRRQMRNDHLVLLVDLQDRQQLVWX
6LMRLWDODLWHNDXDNVLVLJQDDOLDKlLULWVHYLVWlODLWWHLVWDUDGLRWYWLHWRNRQH
9lOWlVLMRLWWDPDVWDODLWHWWDPHWDOOLOHY\MHQYLHUHHQ
6XOMHWXWWLODWNDXSSDNHVNXVOHQWRWHUPLQDDOLWHROOLVXXVKDOOLYRLYDWKDLWDWDVLJQDDOLD
NHVNXV\NVLNN|PHQHHDXWRPDDWWLVHVWLSDULWXVWLODDQ$QWHQQLPHUNNLV\WW\\
3DLQD>6&$1@SDLQLNHWWDMRV
3DLQD>5(6(7@SDLQLNHWWDDQWXULQDODRVDVVD2QQLVWXQHHQSDULWXNVHQMlONHHQNHOOR
DVHWWDDDMDQDXWRPDDWWLVHVWLUDGLRRKMDWXOOD5&VLJQDDOLOODNXWHQV\PEROLRVRLWWDD
$MDQD
VHWXV
.HVNXV\NVLNN|\ULWWllKDNHDDMDQDXWRPDDWWLVHVWLDWRPLNHOORVWD$OXHLOODMRLVVDWlPlHLROH
PDKGROOLVWDYRLWDVHWWDDDMDQPDQXDDOLVHVWL$VHWDHQVLQDLNDVLJQDDOLQYDVWDDQRWWRSRLVSllOWl
SLWlPlOOl>5&&@SDLQLNHWWDSDLQHWWXQDVHNXQQLQDMDQNXQQHV2))WHNVWLWXOHHNHOORRQ
-RV
/&'Qä\WWööQHLWXOHPLWääQSDULVWRMHQDVHWWDPLVHQMäONHHQSDLQD>5(6(7@SDLQLNHWWD
WHUäYäOOäHVLQHHOOä
-RLVVDNLQ
WDSDXNVLVVDHWYäOWWäPäWWäYDVWDDQRWD5&VLJQDDOLDYäOLWWöPäVWLLOPDNHKäQ
.
HOORQDVHWXVPDQXDDOLVHVWL
3DLQDMDSLGl>&/2&.@SDLQLNHWWDSDLQHWWXQDVHNXQWLDNXQQHVWDLKYLONNXX
.ä\Wä>83@
>'2:1@SDLQLNNHLWDVääWääNVHVLNHOORDMDSDLQD>&/2&.@SDLQLNHWWD
VLLUW\äNVHVLVHXUDDYDDQDVHWXNVHHQ
7RLVWDWHGHOOLVWHQNRKWLHQWRLPHWDVHWWDDNVHVLPRRGLQWXQWLPLQXXWWLYXRVL
NXXNDXVLMDSäLYäVHNä'67NHVäWDOYLDLNDDUYRWRLNHLNVL
'$
7(0217+ 0217+ '$7(
+2852))6(7/$1*8$*(DQG'67
3DULOLLWRVDQWXULQMDNHVNXV\NVLN
Ƃ
QY
ć
OLOOH
$VHQQHWWXDVLSDULVWRWNHVNXV\NVLNN|PHQHHDXWRPDDWWLVHVWLWLODDQMRVVDVHKDNHHDQWXULD
$QWHQQLV\PEROLYLONNXX
.XQSDULOLLWRVRQRQQLVWXQXW
DQWHQQLPHUNNLHLHQllYLONXMD
PLWWDXVOXNHPDW
LOPHVW\YlWQl\W|OOH
3DULVWRMHQYDLKWDPLQHQ
.XQYDLKGDWDQWXULLQSDULVWRWRQSDULOLLWRVWHKWlYlXXGHOOHHQPDQXDDOLVHVWL
/DLWHSRLVWXXDVHWXVWRLPLQQRVWDMRVPLWllQQlSSlLQWlHLSDLQHWDVHNXQWLLQ
$LNDY\
ö
K\NHDVHWXV
NRVNHHYDLQ3RKMRLV$PHULNDQYHUVLRWDMRVVDODLWHYDVWDDQRWWDD::9%
VLJQDDOLD.ä\WWäMäYRLYDOLWD367067&67(67$67WDL167
7XQWLRIIVHWRQHXURRSSDODLVLVVDYHUVLRLVVDHUR6DNVDQDMDVWDMDVHYRLGDDQDVHWWDDMD
WXQQLQYlOLOOH6XRPHQMD6DNVDQDLNDHURRQWXQWL
.LHOLYDLKWRHKGRWRYDWHQJODQWL(1UDQVND)5VDNVD'(HVSDQMD(6LWDOLD,7KROODQWL
1/MDYHQlMl58
'67NHVlWDOYLDLNDWRLPLQWRRQDVHWHWWXWLODDQ$XWRWHKGDVDVHWXV.HOORRQRKMHOPRLWX
VllWlPllQDLNDDDXWRPDDWWLVHVWLWXQQLOODHWHHQSlLQNXQNHVlDLND'67RQYRLPDVVD
.l\WWlMlYRLSRLVWDDDXWRPDWLLNDQNl\W|VWlDVHWWDPDOOD'67DVHWXNVHNVL2))
3DLQD>5(6(7@SDLQLNHWWDDQWXULVVD
3DLQD>6&$1@SDLQLNHWWDNHVNXV\NVLN|VVl
3DLQDPDOOD>5(6(7@QDSSLDDQWXULVVDVHOXRDLQDXXGHQSDULOLLWRVNRRGLQMDSDULOLLWRV
SLWääWHKGä\OOäNXYDWXOODWDYDOOD
.LHUUäWäSDULVWRWDLQDDVLDQPXNDLVHHQNLHUUäW\VSLVWHHVHHQ
NP)UDQNIXUWLVWD6DNVDVWD
NP$QWKRUQLVWD(QJODQQLVWD
NP)RUWLVWD&ROOLQVLVWD&RORUDGRVWD
5DGLRRKMDWXQDWRPLNHOORQWRLPLQQRW
.HVNXV\NVLN|QNHOORRQRKMHOPRLWXV\QNURQRLWXPDDQDWRPLNHOORQUDGLRVLJQDDOLLQ
-DOXVWDMDSDULVWRMHQDVHQQXV
.HVNXV\NVLNN|RQVXXQQLWHOWXWRLPLPDDQS|\GlOOlWDLVHLQlOOl
.HVNXV\NVLN|QNHOORKDNHHUDGLRVLJQDDOLDSlLYLWWlLQ
´V\PEROLRQQLVWXQHHVWD
DWRPLNHOORQVLJQDDOLQ
OXHQQDVWD
3RLVWDSDULVWROXXNNX
/DLWDSDLNRLOOHHQ
$$NRNRLVHWSDULVWRWNSOQDSDLVXXVPHUNLQ³´PXNDLVHVWL
$VHQQDSDULVWRNRWHORQOXXNNXWDNDLVLQ
.XQSDULVWRWRQDVHQQHWWXNDLNNL/&'Ql\W|QVHJPHQWLWV\WW\YlWKHWNHNVLMDVLWWHQ
(WlLV\\VDWRPLNHOORVWDMDUDNHQQHWWX\PSlULVW|YRLYDWYDLNXWWDDUDGLRVLJQDDOLQ
YDVWDDQRWWRRQMRNDHLVLLVDLQDRQQLVWX
6LMRLWDODLWHNDXDNVLVLJQDDOLDKlLULWVHYLVWlODLWWHLVWDUDGLRWYWLHWRNRQH
9lOWlVLMRLWWDPDVWDODLWHWWDPHWDOOLOHY\MHQYLHUHHQ
6XOMHWXWWLODWNDXSSDNHVNXVOHQWRWHUPLQDDOLWHROOLVXXVKDOOLYRLYDWKDLWDWDVLJQDDOLD
NHVNXV\NVLNN|PHQHHDXWRPDDWWLVHVWLSDULWXVWLODDQ$QWHQQLPHUNNLV\WW\\
3DLQD>6&$1@SDLQLNHWWDMRV
3DLQD>5(6(7@SDLQLNHWWDDQWXULQDODRVDVVD2QQLVWXQHHQSDULWXNVHQMlONHHQNHOOR
DVHWWDDDMDQDXWRPDDWWLVHVWLUDGLRRKMDWXOOD5&VLJQDDOLOODNXWHQV\PEROLRVRLWWDD
$MDQD
VHWXV
.HVNXV\NVLNN|\ULWWllKDNHDDMDQDXWRPDDWWLVHVWLDWRPLNHOORVWD$OXHLOODMRLVVDWlPlHLROH
PDKGROOLVWDYRLWDVHWWDDDMDQPDQXDDOLVHVWL$VHWDHQVLQDLNDVLJQDDOLQYDVWDDQRWWRSRLVSllOWl
SLWlPlOOl>5&&@SDLQLNHWWDSDLQHWWXQDVHNXQQLQDMDQNXQQHV2))WHNVWLWXOHHNHOORRQ
+820$8786
-RV
/&'Qä\WWööQHLWXOHPLWääQSDULVWRMHQDVHWWDPLVHQMäONHHQSDLQD>5(6(7@SDLQLNHWWD
WHUäYäOOäHVLQHHOOä
-RLVVDNLQ
WDSDXNVLVVDHWYäOWWäPäWWäYDVWDDQRWD5&VLJQDDOLDYäOLWWöPäVWLLOPDNHKäQ
KäLULöQYXRNVL
.
HOORQDVHWXVPDQXDDOLVHVWL
3DLQDMDSLGl>&/2&.@SDLQLNHWWDSDLQHWWXQDVHNXQWLDNXQQHVWDLKYLONNXX
.ä\Wä>83@
>'2:1@SDLQLNNHLWDVääWääNVHVLNHOORDMDSDLQD>&/2&.@SDLQLNHWWD
VLLUW\äNVHVLVHXUDDYDDQDVHWXNVHHQ
7RLVWDWHGHOOLVWHQNRKWLHQWRLPHWDVHWWDDNVHVLPRRGLQWXQWLPLQXXWWLYXRVL
NXXNDXVLMDSäLYäVHNä'67NHVäWDOYLDLNDDUYRWRLNHLNVL
'$
7(0217+ 0217+ '$7(
+2852))6(7/$1*8$*(DQG'67
3DULOLLWRVDQWXULQMDNHVNXV\NVLN
Ƃ
QY
ć
OLOOH
$VHQQHWWXDVLSDULVWRWNHVNXV\NVLNN|PHQHHDXWRPDDWWLVHVWLWLODDQMRVVDVHKDNHHDQWXULD
$QWHQQLV\PEROLYLONNXX
.XQSDULOLLWRVRQRQQLVWXQXW
DQWHQQLPHUNNLHLHQllYLONXMD
PLWWDXVOXNHPDW
LOPHVW\YlWQl\W|OOH
3DULVWRMHQYDLKWDPLQHQ
.XQYDLKGDWDQWXULLQSDULVWRWRQSDULOLLWRVWHKWlYlXXGHOOHHQPDQXDDOLVHVWL
/DLWHSRLVWXXDVHWXVWRLPLQQRVWDMRVPLWllQQlSSlLQWlHLSDLQHWDVHNXQWLLQ
$LNDY\
ö
K\NHDVHWXV
NRVNHHYDLQ3RKMRLV$PHULNDQYHUVLRWDMRVVDODLWHYDVWDDQRWWDD::9%
VLJQDDOLD.ä\WWäMäYRLYDOLWD367067&67(67$67WDL167
7XQWLRIIVHWRQHXURRSSDODLVLVVDYHUVLRLVVDHUR6DNVDQDMDVWDMDVHYRLGDDQDVHWWDDMD
WXQQLQYlOLOOH6XRPHQMD6DNVDQDLNDHURRQWXQWL
.LHOLYDLKWRHKGRWRYDWHQJODQWL(1UDQVND)5VDNVD'(HVSDQMD(6LWDOLD,7KROODQWL
1/MDYHQlMl58
'67NHVlWDOYLDLNDWRLPLQWRRQDVHWHWWXWLODDQ$XWRWHKGDVDVHWXV.HOORRQRKMHOPRLWX
VllWlPllQDLNDDDXWRPDDWWLVHVWLWXQQLOODHWHHQSlLQNXQNHVlDLND'67RQYRLPDVVD
.l\WWlMlYRLSRLVWDDDXWRPDWLLNDQNl\W|VWlDVHWWDPDOOD'67DVHWXNVHNVL2))
9DLKGDSDULVWRWXXVLLQ
3DLQD>5(6(7@SDLQLNHWWDDQWXULVVD
3DLQD>6&$1@SDLQLNHWWDNHVNXV\NVLN|VVl
+820$8786
3DLQDPDOOD>5(6(7@QDSSLDDQWXULVVDVHOXRDLQDXXGHQSDULOLLWRVNRRGLQMDSDULOLLWRV
SLWääWHKGä\OOäNXYDWXOODWDYDOOD
.LHUUäWäSDULVWRWDLQDDVLDQPXNDLVHHQNLHUUäW\VSLVWHHVHHQ
NP)UDQNIXUWLVWD6DNVDVWD
NP$QWKRUQLVWD(QJODQQLVWD
NP)RUWLVWD&ROOLQVLVWD&RORUDGRVWD