Page 3–18   
UPLC-II™ System Manual
3.5.2 Permissive Overreaching
Transfer Trip Systems
Overreaching transfer trip systems require a chan-
nel signal to trip, and are used with a frequency-
shift audio tone, modulated  on  a communication
channel  (e.g.,  public  or  private  telephone  lines).
These systems are generally not used with Power-
Line  Carriers.  There  are,  however,  successful
applications  of  Power-Line  Carrier  on  POTT
schemes where parallel lines allow for cross-cou-
pling of the carrier signal.
3.5.3 Permissive and Non-Permissive
Underreaching Transfer Trip
Systems
For  overreaching  systems,  the  directional  phase
and ground trip fault detectors (P) must be set to
overlap within the transmission line and not over-
reach any terminals (see Figure 3–10). 
That  is,  at  least  one  trip  fault  detector  (P)  must
operate  for  all  internal  faults,  and  none  should
operate for any external fault. In practice, distance
relays are normally required for both ground faults
and  phase  faults,  although  directional  instanta-
neous ground-overcurrent relays might meet these
requirements in some cases. 
Though it is the least complex, the non-permissive
system is rarely used because of the high potential
for  false outputs from the  channel,  which  would
cause incorrect tripping. If a non-permissive sys-
tem is used, the channel considerations should be
as described later for direct trip systems. The sys-
tem  is  made  permissive  by  the  additional  set  of
phase  and  ground  overreaching  fault  detectors
(FD),  which  must  operate  for  all  internal  faults
(see Figure 3–10). 
Operation  of  the  underreaching  transfer  trip
scheme  shown  in  Figure 3–10  is  described  in
Table 3–5 for external and internal faults. 
Because the trip fault detectors (P) do not operate
for external faults, underreaching transfer trip sys-
tems do not require external fault-clearing coordi-
nation circuits (transient blocking) and are, there-
fore,  inherently  simpler  than  any  of  the  other
schemes. You obtain maximum security if you use
additional  permissive  fault  detectors.  These
schemes  also  provide  minimum  operating  times
for  many faults that are tripped directly,  without
using the channel.
3.5.4 Dual Phase Comparison
Unblocking Systems
Dual comparison systems require a duplex chan-
nel:  one  frequency  for  each  line  terminal.  The
UPLC-II™ frequency-shift channel equipment is
available  for  this  purpose;  normally  used  in  an
unblocking system. Continuous channel monitor-
ing is also provided, because either a trip positive
or trip negative carrier signal is always transmit-
ted. 
The  transmitter  is  keyed  to  its  trip  positive  fre-
quency when the square wave from the filter goes
positive, and is keyed to its trip negative frequen-
cy when the square wave is at zero. There are two
outputs at the receiver: the trip positive output is a
square wave  that goes positive when a trip posi-
tive frequency is received; the trip negative output
goes  positive  when  a  trip  negative  frequency  is
received. 
The  basic  operation  of  the  Dual  Phase
Comparison system is shown in Figure 3–11. For
internal  faults,  the  single  phase  outputs  of  the
sequence  current  networks  are  essentially  in
phase,  although  such  output  represents  currents
180° apart in the power system. The network out-
put goes through a squaring amplifier that keys the
frequency  shift  transmitter.  An  adjustable  delay
circuit  delays  the  local  square  wave  by  a  time
equal to the channel delay time. 
The  network  output  is  then  used  to  develop  two
complementary  square  waves.  One  wave,  which
has a positive state during the positive half-cycle
of the sequence current network, is compared with