VCG202/EN M/H11
 
 
Technical 
 
 
Figure 16:  Negative reactance control 2 
Figures 15 and 16 mimic Figures 13 and 14 except that in this case all the compensation 
elements which are reactive have been reversed, the resistive elements being 
unchanged. It can now be seen that the transformer with a low volts condition is 
presenting a regulating voltage Vreg which is lower than Vrem (the required voltage) and 
hence a raise volts command is given. The opposite is true for the transformer that has 
too high a voltage. The net result is that the transformers are forced together eliminating 
the circulating current. 
Where negative reactance control is used it should be noted that the setting applied to 
the relay is now based on the transformer reactance and not the line reactance to enable 
correct compensation. This will introduce an error in regulation which can be seen in both 
Figures 15 and 16. In both cases when the circulating current is zero the  relays will 
regulate to Vrem. This value of Vrem is different to that from Figures 13 and 14 (also 
shown as dotted lines on Figures 15 and 16). In practice this error is very small for a unity 
power factor load current. 
The above diagrams demonstrate how reverse reactance control is used to eliminate 
circulating current.  All the above figures also assume that line drop compensation is 
being used as well.  This is not necessarily the case.  If LDC is not required then the 
resistive compensation will not be needed and can be set to zero and only the reactive 
compensation will be set (in the negative sense). Figure 17 shows this arrangement and 
assumes that the reverse reactance compounding has eliminated the circulating current.  
It is noted from the figure that load current will still be passing through the reactive 
compensation circuit producing a certain amount of compensation (where none should be 
present). In effect this load current compensation is purely an error signal.  Again, in 
practice this error is small.  
 
Figure 17:  Negative reactance control at unity power factor 
Figure 17 shows the effect of load current on negative reactance control with a unity 
power factor.  Where the power factor is not unity then it is possible to use the resistive